I don't confess to know enough about the whole subject to give a confident opinion.
However, I work on oil rigs with a large majority of Scots. Speaking to them (well the more educated ones) they are not looking forward to this referendum at all, especially now the teenagers are aloud the vote.
You can predict how it'll go.....every night for a week before the vote - Braveheart on TV , painted faces everywhere and a vote for independence . I don't think it'll be a good thing.
And what about in 60 years when all the oil has gone and Scotland has to rely on fishing and tourism? become British again??