I’ve read the 115 page transcript and Andrew Benson of the BBC has missed the point completely.
McLaren were found guilty of breaching article 151c of the International Sporting Code back in July. The September 13 hearing was to present new evidence that could of altered the punishment (or lack of) issued in July. The evidence presented showed that other current information other than the dossier was filtering into the McLaren team. It showed that not just Coughlan and Stepney were involved.
Coughlan was in possession of enough data to build, run and test a 2007 Ferrari. In the Toyota case the data was one year old. I wasn’t aware of anyone going to jail. My understanding was that Ferrari actually sold the data to Toyota.
The drivers should have been banned as part of the punished because if you are going to suggest the data was likely to of been used then the drivers would of benefited. Obviously its understandable that they weren’t for financial interests and the fans would of taken it very badly. Offering immunity was a very sneaky way round it.
To put it simply it was impossible to say Ferrari info was not used in the design/development of the McLaren car.
I think Ron actually accepts that this is a real possibility that cannot be ignored. Therefore he is focusing on finishing the drivers championship, doing some house keeping (i.e. Alonso, possibly Pedro and maybe a few others) and getting the 2008 car 100% ready to be allowed into the 2008 championship and fight for it.
One other thing Ron has to deal with is Jonathan Neale (Managing Director, Mclaren Racing). Neale meet with Coughlan in March and became aware that Coughlan had been receiving data from Stepney.
To quote Ian Mill, QC for McLaren
“we think that Mr Neale should not have turned a blind eye, being a manager, and thus should be penalisedâ€