I seriously considered spending a lot more money than my HR on a new Astra VXR, was even in a showroom at one point discussing specs but thankfully I bailed lol. The Zed (especially the minor HR facial tweeks) still looks fresh today and parked up, despite the arches and bulge it sits looking very smart indeed. Nothing sticking out, no spoilers etc, just a good honest special looking car. The Astra is a good looking car but I wouldn't say special. Again I'm biased as I'm not into spoilers everywhere and boy racer looks...but then again.. I did nearly go for one. (sometimes wondering how much cheaper to run it'd be when the Zed running costs come about ) Power wise I'd love to see a rolling start on a youtube video between them would be good, but otherwise in the real 30-60, car park world, the Zed I think has the Astra for ...'kerb appeal' or whatever. Theres just something nicer about a car that looks good..on its own, no additions. I do like the Astra big wheels though... My only concern with the Astra when I looked at one is why is it so big?!