The only thing I didn't agree with CH about 370Z in his review was the seating position, I think it's rather good, apart from the massive A pillars and wing mirrors.
Other than that, I probably agree on most of his thoughts. That said, drive the 370Z back to back with a Caymen S and a GT86 was always going to highlight certain factors like weight and handling.
I still bought a 370Z though because I wanted one.