Jump to content

Help with a car choice. DS3 or Qashqai or...?


rabbitstew

Recommended Posts

The missus is due a new company car, so we spent a lot of the weekend checking out what cars are out there in her allowed budget etc...

 

So we looked at:

 

Honda Civic - she likes the spaceship dash & front lights...

Honda Jazz - too boxy

Renault Megane - liked looked outside and big boot, but inside she thought was rubbish

Peugeot 308 - she ruled this out within seconds, looked too dated.

Nissan Juke - She loved the way it looked, but no boot on it hardly at all, and inside felt quite cramped.

Ford Fiesta / Fusion - too small & boring (she says)

Ford Focus - old mans car, and indeed, her old man has one.

Vauxhall Astra - possibly.. need to check one out in more detail.

 

 

So shes narrowed it down atm to:

 

Citroen DS3 DStyle Plus - 90bhp 1.5 diesel. You seem to get a good spec with this pack. We drove the 110bhp version and it was a really nice drive, sporty ride, very responsive - turbo kicks in low down and was quite economical & comfortable. Inside was surprisingly spacious. Im 6ft and could happily sit in the back of one with loads of room for such a small car. Only question mark she has is cos its a small car, the boot with the back seats up isnt as big as say the megane or the 308. Personally I loved it, and could see id have loads of fun in it, although I was worried about the French build quality - would the car fall apart after a few weeks. Interestingly a brand new one of these was coming in at less than I paid for my 4 year old zed.

 

Nissan Qashqai - Yet to have a good look around one, but she likes the idea of this sort of car and hopes the inside & boot is bigger than the juke.

 

Too very different cars surprisingly enough. Her car "allowance" is crap, so it would have to be something like a 1.5/1.6 sized car, she does 30k a year so we`re mainly looking at diesels, although with the Hondas they were petrol as apparently Honda arnt making another diesel Civic until next March.

 

Anyone got one of the above or any experience of them? What did you think?

 

Any other cars we should be considering? BMW 1 series is just outside her budget. Audi A1 just about falls in there, but think its going to be too small.... Skoda again she thinks looks old man, and she doesnt fancy a KIA or Hyundi.... Not much else left im thinking?

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Not trying to sound too biased, but the QQ is a great all-rounder, I would def look at the DCI's rather than the petrol’s, and the new 1.6dci is great. Pity you were not a bit closer to the North East I would have loaned you one for the day!

 

Click on my Blue Banner below, the link will take you to the offers we have on, to give you an idea to what is out there deals wise :thumbs:

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Its not so much a specified size, but what her car allowance will cover. She does cart a lot of rubbish about in her car as part of her job, so something "golf" or "focus" sized is what she has been looking at in order to get a reasonable sized boot. But with her allowance only covering smaller sized engines, we didnt want the car to be too under powered.

 

The QashQai 1.6dci falls within the allowance by the looks of it - its on the companies "spreadsheet of approved cars". My only concern was would the 1.6 be too revvy. Im used to 1.9 or 2.0 turbo diesels which kick out 100->140bhp, and whilst it looks like the 1.6Dci does produce a reasonable amount of power, it must have a big turbo on it or be revvy to get that power?

 

Ive been reading up a few reviews and they do seem to get good reviews! I`ll have to try and get a drive in one. Problem is, we are busy for the next 3 weekends and she needs to put her order in before then. May have to get a day off work or something I think or pop down my local garage at lunchtime.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

I have a load of stuff on the 1.6dci, if you want it let me know

T

 

Cheers Mate

 

http://www.alfagiulietta.com/giulietta/com/index.html

 

My son and his partner have just bought one - 140bhp diesel, twin pipes and all the toys and goes well too :thumbs:

 

yep, she likes them too!!! Just been looking at them and it would cost us an extra 150quid a month, but they look awesome. Apparently 60mpg and 0-60 in 7.7seconds.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

I have a load of stuff on the 1.6dci, if you want it let me know

T

 

Cheers Mate

 

Just PM me an email address, as most of the stuff is quite large on Excel & PDF, whenever :thumbs:

 

Will do. Intrequed as to what the difference is between the 1.5 and 1.6 diesels? On paper looks like very little, so why have 2? The 2.0 looks a bit more pokey, but the fuel economy drops loads.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

I have a QQ company car which the wife uses and it's great. It's only the 1.6 petrol but manages ok, looks great in silver, and is really big inside. We went for the Ntec spec with glass roof, sat nav etc. really good value and an all round ideal utility car. They've sold over a million for a reason!

Link to comment
Share on other sites

I have a QQ company car which the wife uses and it's great. It's only the 1.6 petrol but manages ok, looks great in silver, and is really big inside. We went for the Ntec spec with glass roof, sat nav etc. really good value and an all round ideal utility car. They've sold over a million for a reason!

 

What sort of mpg does the 1.6 petrol get in normal use?

Link to comment
Share on other sites

My big sister has a full spec 2.0 petrol 4x4 qashqai, bought it new 4 years ago. It's a good car and even on the oem tyres she had no issues in the snow over the past few years. We live in a place that gets lots of snow and has 'hill' in the title..... As you can imagine, there are plenty inclines and her drive is steep too. No problems at all. She has used it with her child and all the crap that she routinely carts about.

It's not the biggest car (Mums CRV dwarfs it) but it's comfortable and capable.

You can do a lot worse than a qashqai in my opinion.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Okay well just popped down my local Nissan dealer to have a quick snout about at the QashQai. After a good ten minutes or more of climbing in and out of cars, finally someone asks me if I need a hand. However, unfortunately all their sales people are busy.... looking about, busy means they only have 1 sales person on duty by the looks of it and they are sealing a deal on a car.

 

The base model QashQai did look very boring and plain, but the N-Tec spec one they had sitting there did look very nice. Ive booked a test drive for tomorrow so will see what its like on the road.

 

Only problem is, revisiting the spreadsheet of cars which the missus`s company have given her, only the lower 1.5Dci and the 1.6 petrol Acenta models fall within her bracket. Whereas with the Juke, because its a cheaper car, we could get a higher spec model for the same price.... so, looks like the Juke may be back in the equation. Sigh. Im tempted to just leave her too it, as i know she`ll end up going with the car which is the best colour, or has the cutest looking headlamps or something..... argh!

Link to comment
Share on other sites

I have a load of stuff on the 1.6dci, if you want it let me know

T

 

Cheers Mate

 

Just PM me an email address, as most of the stuff is quite large on Excel & PDF, whenever :thumbs:

 

Will do. Intrequed as to what the difference is between the 1.5 and 1.6 diesels? On paper looks like very little, so why have 2? The 2.0 looks a bit more pokey, but the fuel economy drops loads.

 

The 1.6DCI is to ultimately replace the 2.0cdi believe it or not! expect in the 4x4 guise

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

×   Pasted as rich text.   Paste as plain text instead

  Only 75 emoji are allowed.

×   Your link has been automatically embedded.   Display as a link instead

×   Your previous content has been restored.   Clear editor

×   You cannot paste images directly. Upload or insert images from URL.

×
×
  • Create New...