That tyre review site is populated by morons. Read the actual text from the users and it's clear that 95% of them have no clue what a decent tyre should be. All they do is say that their current tyre is great because they spent their hard-earned on it and don't want to lose face by saying they made a mistake.
Any tyre will aquaplane, so no-one can say a tyre will never do it. Basically you have three camps: Track stuff like the R888, normal tyres like the MPSS, and winter tyres. There will be margins between those three sets, but basically you're exchanging dry grip for wet grip as you move down the list.
You don't need winter tyres, but they are much better in cold conditions. I run 050As all year round and just drive to the conditions, and that's all you need to do really. Eagle F1s are good, 050A are good, MPSS are good. You won't go wrong with any of them, but the extra wear plus extra dry grip means the MPSS stand out for me.