Just not true, Rob.
From last month's EVO's choices:-
Supermini - Fiat Panda 100HP
Hot Hatch - Megane R26
Small Coupe - Zed
Sports Saloon - M3
Big Saloon - M5
4X4/Estates - M5 Touring
Sports Cars - Boxster
Coupes/GTs - GT-R
Convertibles - XKR
Supercars - Ferrari 599GTB
IIRC their best handling FWD car was a Teg.
I could go on....
Without going back and looking at other cars they include in the categories, I'm not sure what the summaries mean. But 30% of them go to BMW, so I'm not wrong there! I am referring to the articles themselves, and the constant references to '3 series' this and '911' that. Just as I find it. I love cars with a passion, but I just find their reviews predictable.
Rather less predictable of late - R8 trumps 911, GT-R trumps R8...
I suspect the BMWs are there because they are the best in class. Clearly you don't like the mag and that's fine but there really isn't a German/overpriced bias beyond the fact that the Germans make a lot of mighty fine cars.
Maybe you have an anti-German bias...
No anti German bias at all, I'd love many Mercs and even the odd Audi.
As I say, it is just as I find it, and I have not read it for a good 12 months on that basis. If it has changed, so be it. I may not have any affection for BMW, granted. It was just in the little articles and reviews of any new car, I felt the references were OTT.