I get the comparison with Japanese cars in the 80s, but it doesn’t really fit the situation today. Back then the issue was perception, not engineering. The Japanese stuff was already mechanically brilliant — light, simple, over‑engineered and reliable. People mocked them because they were new and cheap, not because they were badly built.
With modern Chinese EVs the question isn’t “can they pass a crash test?” — clearly they can. The real unknown is long‑term durability, battery ageing, software support, corrosion protection, and how they hold up after 10–15 years of British weather and potholes. That’s the bit we simply don’t have data for yet. Phones and laptops being made in China doesn’t tell you anything about how a 2‑tonne EV copes with structural fatigue or inverter failures a decade down the line.
Sales numbers don’t prove engineering quality either. MG and BYD are selling because they’re cheap, subsidised and loaded with gadgets. Fair play to them — competition is good. But comparing that to something like a Zed, which we know can do 150k+ miles without turning into a laptop on wheels, is apples and oranges. One is a long‑term mechanical machine, the other is a short‑cycle consumer product with a battery pack.
On the weight thing — yes, everything has gained weight, but a 2‑tonne AMG GT is heavy because it’s carrying a twin‑turbo V8, a transaxle, a DCT and a full cooling system. A 2‑tonne EV is heavy because the battery alone weighs half a tonne. Not the same engineering challenge, not the same compromises. And sure, some niche EV brands have solved charging or weight for their segment, but that doesn’t magically make every heavy EV a “sports car”.
Charging for a fiver is great, but running costs don’t equal build quality. They don’t tell you anything about how the suspension arms, bushings, seals, battery, or electronics will look in 2035.
And just to put it in perspective — a 25‑year‑old Skyline GT‑R now commands a six digit price tag, deservedly, and still looks as good today as it did back then. I’ll happily wager no Chinese EV will ever be that car, or hold that kind of legacy.