I'm sorry but I hate posts like this. How are we supposed to know who will be cheaper for you?
We don't know if you're male/female, where you live, where it's parked, how long you've had a license, if you have any convictions, claims or non motoring offences etc etc
Go to the usual go compare, compare the market, money supermarket etc and put your info in. Our crystal balls will give us nothing I'm afraid!
Good luck