I bought these from Tarmac sportz last year, they were the last of his old style spats (which I actually prefer as the top line is thinner and blends into the car better). Buster and I sprayed these with a rattle can but came up well. The outer/most visible side of these spats are in good condition, the underside is a bit tatty and the bit just behind the rear wheel has been peppered with stone chips. But you can't really see these bits.
The fit is better than most, not perfect but good, I have seen far worse fitting rear spats, but you never get 100% unless they are genuine. They would ideally need repainting, but the exterior blue was fine so never really bothered me.
Pics below of the spats, and the last one shows them fitted to my car recently. Good fit and pretty good colour match
Looking to get my money back on these, £50 delivered.