ive just had my insurance renewel last month, i too was with Aplan last year but my renewel had gone up from £1500 to £1666 so i rang round the usual suspects that youve listed and got the cheapest qoute from Adrian Flux of £1100 so then rang sky who had quoted my £1300 and they matchd my best quote of £1100. Which i was well happy with as ide sooner be with sky as they seem to be really genuine people who care about cars i want to help u the best they can