When I was looking for a new car, my sort list was 370z, Cayman S, Audi S5, Audi RS4 and M3. The 370z was only an 11 plate when the rest were 2009 or older. I bought the 370z not as raw as the 350z but you can drive it in comfort but when you have a bad day at work you can give it some beans and put a smile back on your face.
Go for 370Z you won't regret it